Beasthood (The Hidden Blood Series)
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. There will be spoilers.
I’m not a big fan of romance, although I don’t have anything against it. I can still get into a story if it’s built up well.
And I don’t have any intention of discouraging the author from writing more. Even though I personally didn’t like the book I do hope she finishes this for the people who do like the book. The story ended on a cliff hanger and I’ll admit I’m mildly curious about the answer.
The story also had a strong start. In the first few chapters we’re introduced to Jaz and her recent problems. She had a traumatic experience a year ago that she’s still attempting to recover from and people are skeptical about what she believes is the truth. It sets up a good conflict where people on both sides can be understandable.
There were some parts, particularly at the end, that were exciting.
I should explain why I’m giving this book the score that I am, though. I’ll try to be thorough.
There were some small issues the book had. There were a lot of parts with telling rather than showing.
Two examples I can think of off the top of my head:
When Jaz suddenly starts talking to Maria we’re informed that they’d gotten to know each other over the course of the last few days. We don’t see it. One day they’re strangers, and the next time we read about them Jaz has developed a connection with her.
Another example is when Jaz is given the nickname “Skin”. I’m not even sure why she was given that nickname. She just has it one day and everyone starts calling her by it (this is towards the last half of the book, too, so the sudden switch was jarring).
This could have been fixed easily in some parts.
Example: Nik was itching with impatience but he was very good at self-control. He reined it in and told himself over and over again that it would take time. Just wait, he chanted inwardly.
This is a lighter example where we’re told that he has a lot of self-control.
Compare it with a simple revision like this:
“Nik was itching with impatience but held it in. Just wait, he chanted inwardly.”
It’s more succinct and instead of being told he’s good and self-control it shows it more.
Another example:
“…and Saga -a dark-haired, curvy woman with long black hair who was the Spokesperson for Weaponry and Training Facilities. All her family had been killed years ago in the civil Pack wars; her only relation she knew of was her distant cousin Fraya, who was standing behind her.”
This is the first time I think we’re even hearing of Saga and all of this is dumped on us.
There was also a habit of using “-“s a lot. I believe it was only said twice, but it also says Jaz’s eyes are kyanite colored. I wouldn’t say this was a major issue the book had because I don’t recall anything else where a bizarre word was used instead of a simple word, but saying something like “blue” or “deep blue” would have worked better in those two instances.
Some parts didn’t make sense to me.
“The night sky was clear: he’d seen when he’d gone out for a smoke not long ago. He didn’t smoke; that just proved how stressted out he was.”
If he doesn’t smoke then why does he have something to smoke in the first place? As a non-smoker, I don’t find the thought of smoking relaxing at all. There’s no addiction so there’s no drive to do it. Taking a deep breath would be far more suitable.
There was also a part where someone was wearing three inch heels during construction work.
Those were the minor issues I had.
The issue that I had with this book that I couldn’t get over was the characters actions and how the actions were treated.
I was frustrated by chapter 12 because no one had even attempted to talk to Jaz despite numerous opportunities for them to do things in a far less traumatic way. Even after finishing the book there was never a good explanation.
They expect Jaz to like them and eventually come to trust them, but they didn’t talk to her, comfort her, or even attempt to bring her into their group in a civil manner.
To explain it better: Jaz has recently been introduced to a relative of hers named Erica. Erica invites her to vacation with her somewhere. Jaz ends up in a car with her, her husband and a driver.
On the way there they drug her orange juice and she ends up getting very sick. She doesn’t know they drugged her. She just thinks she’s sick.
She has to throw up, so before they arrive at their destination she makes them pull over so she can throw up in the woods. While she’s throwing up she notices two people in the woods.
And because she sees people in the woods? She gets grabbed and restrained by the driver, operated on while she’s unconscious to remove her toenails, as well as prodded in more intimate areas to check if she’s fertile, then thrown into a cell and held captive for days.
Not taking into account the fact that they drugged her and made her sick to begin with, the way they handled her seeing people in the woods made zero sense.
Much later in the book we see that the two people are incredibly severely punished for having been spotted, because it “forced them to bring her in the way they did”. Why? I have no idea. She barely knew any of the people she was with and she saw people in the woods. She had no reason to believe they were connected to each other, or even that there was some sort of problem with people being in the woods.
The group she was with could have easily shrugged and said, “Must be hunters”, or hikers, or something. Why they chose to assault her, kidnap her, mutilate her, violate her and hold her hostage in a cell instead bewilders me. They kept her in a cell for days without ever trying to explain anything to her.
Even if they didn’t think she would believe their explanation – which was reasonable – that doesn’t mean not explaining anything. Even if she didn’t believe them, talking to her would have given her an understanding of what they believed and why they were doing what they were doing.
They could have told her their beliefs, dealt with the fact that she wouldn’t believe them right away, and as she changed they could have explained that the things she was experiencing were part of the change.
Almost anyone could have brought her in better than they did.
On top of that they dump sensitive information on her while she’s going through all of this, like telling her she’s adopted and fertile.
To start with, it was unnecessary for them to do an invasive test to see if she was fertile without her permission.
Imagine if instead the broke the subject of her being adopted while on the way their, opening up communication and giving her a chance to ask questions. They could have later brought up that it was possible she really was fertile, and let her decide if she wanted to be tested or not.
That wasn’t the end of it.
There’s a huge problem in this book with the characters showing no respect for Jaz. At 25% through, for her that she should take a shower. They don’t ask her if she wants to take a shower or tell her, “There’s a shower over there if you want it”. At this point in the book they’ve gone out of their way to make me dislike them and every part that shows Driver being sad that Jaz is hurt rings as hollow, because they’re making no attempt to do anything but hurt her.
This book suffers from a huge problem of the characters acting horrifically, but it doesn’t treat it as if they’re acting horrifically. We’re supposed to brush aside what they do and accept them as good guys.
For example, here’s a passage:
“I want you to tell me,” he pushed, gazing at her, unblinking.
She exhaled. “I don’t want to talk about it.”
She then nearly recoils from him when he approaches.
“He eyeballed her. “Is that why you’ve never asked what you are?” he questioned. “You’re afraid?”
She shook her head -more to tell him to shut up than to say no.
“You can’t run away from it.”
“Stop. Okay, just stop,” she snapped.
He blinked and closed his mouth.
She huffed. “I’m just trying to deal with one thing at a time, so will you just back off.””
Then he sits down by the wall and stares at her (though a bit later it says he’s looking at the ground), as if it’s only going to be a few seconds for her to deal with being kidnapped, mutilated and held hostage among other things. This guy is a jerk even when he’s supposed to be being nice. He’s pushy, invasive, and he’s sitting in ‘her’ room staring at her. By all rights that should be absolutely terrifying for anyone in her position. He just asked her if she was scared because he got visual clues that she was probably frightened, and he’s doing this anyway.
This isn’t even mentioning that she was clearly uncomfortable around him and everyone had left her alone with him multiple times already. And continued doing so.
She gets manhandled by him several times in the book, too, all the way through.
They complain that she doesn’t ask questions, but when she does they don’t give her answers. Like, “Who is Lora to you?”
A huge portion of the drama of this story could have been resolved if anyone tried to communicate with Jaz.
When she’s helping with construction another member of the group continuously harasses her and no one does anything about it. We don’t see much of it, but we are told that it happens for days, and Jaz is in a whole group of people.
This cultimates in Fraya challenging her to a duel. We’re eventually given an explanation for why people didn’t try to interfere with a duel, but we’re never given an explanation for why everyone allowed the harassment to continue for all of that time.
Before Jaz was there, Lora is constantly harassed and doesn’t tell anyone because she’s “not one to complain”. Based on how openly she’s harasses and abuses Jaz, I can only assume pretty much everyone knew Lora was being attacked this way regardless of whether she said anything or not.
Somehow Jaz ends up being pinpointed as being guilty of being harsh or cruel, and she’s constantly apologizing when she’s the one owed an apology.
There are so many issues getting attached to characters in this book. Jaz trying boxing for the first time with Carr could be nice – if it wasn’t for the fact that he was allowing her to be harassed and threatened for days prior without doing anything to protect her or even complaining about it.
“She’d been warned. Driver had tried to tell her. She’d been too much of a coward to ask about it. To get his or Maria’s advice. She’d shunned any that was given to her. She’d made anyone stop if they spoke about it, changing the subject or bluntly telling them to move on. Now she regretted it wholeheartedly.”
She was drugged with something that will make her body changed without explanation, operated on without explanation, held in a cell for days without explanation, been harassed without anyone trying to stop it, had knowledge purposefully held from her over and over again for weak reasons, and it’s her fault that she doesn’t trust these people enough to ask them about something?
Both Lora and Jaz can be petty, too. They discover that Nik slept with Fraya once years before he met either of them, and this is a big deal for some reason. Jaz’s virginity is also brought up a few times as if it’s something to be ashamed of.
After getting in a fight with Fraya, Jaz says this:
“”I don’t know what came over me.” she met his eyes. “Will I be punished?””
When I read the fight scene, based on everything else in the book, I was afraid something like this would happen. Fraya was threatening her family. This is something that she should be reporting to people. Instead Jaz says what I wrote above.
“That would be cruelty, and there’s very little a despise more.” [sic]
Nik says this at one point. He brutally punished two people because Jaz saw them in the woods. He’s manhandled and terrified Jaz several times. His words don’t ring true, and I didn’t know how Jaz could believe that statement when she’s witnessed the opposite.
“He stepped forward in irritation. “Stop telling me what I will and won’t understand, what you can and can’t explain and just tell me. Right. Now.””
Nik yells this at Jaz. This is what Jaz should be saying to all of them.
Moments later he’s yelling at her about breaking curfew. Which is, again, something she wouldn’t have done if anyone had bothered to explain to her that she could be murdered if she went out at night.
During the whole book these things were blaring at me. The book wanted to sweep it under the rug and move on, but I couldn’t ignore the questions pecking at my mind. Things like, “Why in the world did they have to treat her so inhumanely?”, “Why isn’t anyone doing anything about this blatant harassment?”, or “Why is the book making out Jaz to be the one who is out of line all the time?”. I needed much better explanations for their actions than what I got.
It’s clear other people have enjoyed the book but I just couldn’t get into it for those reasons. Still, I wish the author luck, and perhaps I will enjoy a different book from her in the future.
I give this book a 2/10.